By Nova Numismatics · Updated November 2026

The short answer: start with the free checks. Weigh the coin, measure it, and compare both with the official figures for that coin. Then try a magnet. Most fakes fail at least one of these. For more certainty, use a density test or ping test, and for full confidence a dedicated tester like a Sigma or an XRF machine. No single test proves a coin is real, so always combine two or three.

The 8 tests at a glance

TestWhat you needCatchesHarms the coin?
1. Look closelyYour eyes, a magnifierPoor copies, wrong detailsNo
2. Weigh itScale accurate to 0.01 gMost fakesNo
3. Measure itDigital callipersFakes made to the right weightNo
4. Magnet testA strong (neodymium) magnetSteel or iron fakesNo
5. Ice testAn ice cubeMany base-metal fakesNo
6. Ping testA phone appWrong metal insideNo
7. Density testScale, cup of water, threadMost fakes, including plated onesNo
8. Pro testersSigma verifier or XRF machineAlmost everythingNo

1. Look closely Free

A magnifying glass held over a silver Maple Leaf coin on a desk

Compare the coin with a photo of a genuine one from the mint’s website. Fakes often give themselves away with soft or blurry details, uneven lettering, the wrong font, a rough or badly spaced edge (the ridges called “reeding”), or a dull, greasy-looking surface.

Newer coins have security features that are very hard to copy:

  • Silver Britannia (2021 onwards): tilt the coin and a small hidden image switches between a padlock and a trident. You should also see waves that seem to move behind Britannia, tiny laser text reading DECUS ET TUTAMEN, and fine lines on the Union Flag on her shield.
  • Silver Maple Leaf (2014 onwards): fine radial lines across the background and a tiny laser-engraved maple leaf on the reverse.

2. Weigh it Under £20

A silver coin on a digital scale reading 31.10 grams

A 1 oz silver coin contains 31.10 g of silver. A cheap digital jewellery scale that reads to 0.01 g is enough. A genuine coin should be within about 0.1 g of the official weight.

Fakes are usually made from copper, nickel or zinc alloys, which are lighter than silver. A fake made to the exact size of a real coin is usually several grams too light.

3. Measure it Under £20

Digital callipers measuring the diameter of a silver coin
Measuring the diameter with digital callipers. Compare your reading with the official figure for your coin in the table below.

Counterfeiters sometimes add weight to get the scale right, but then the coin comes out too thick or the wrong width. Digital callipers measure diameter and thickness to a hundredth of a millimetre. Check your coin against the official figures:

1 oz silver coinWeightDiameterPurity
Britannia (2013 onwards)31.10 g38.61 mm99.9%
Maple Leaf31.11 g38.00 mm99.99%
American Eagle31.10 g40.60 mm99.9%
Krugerrand31.10 g38.70 mm99.9%
Philharmonic31.10 g37.00 mm99.9%
Kangaroo31.10 g40.60 mm99.99%

Figures can vary very slightly between years. For thickness, check the mint’s own specification for your coin’s year.

4. Magnet test Under £10

A neodymium magnet on a tilted silver coin

Silver isn’t magnetic, so a strong neodymium magnet shouldn’t stick to a silver coin. If it sticks, the coin has steel or iron in it and is fake.

A neat extra test: tilt the coin to about 45° and let the magnet slide down it. On real silver the magnet slides down noticeably slowly, because silver gently resists it. On most fake metals it slides off quickly.

The catch: many fakes are made of non-magnetic metals too. Passing the magnet test doesn’t prove a coin is silver, but failing it proves it isn’t.

5. Ice test Free

Ice cubes on a silver coin and on a base-metal coin; the ice on the silver melts faster

Silver conducts heat better than any other metal. Put an ice cube on the coin and one on a similar-sized coin of another metal, and watch. On silver the ice starts melting straight away, as if the coin were warm.

The catch: copper also conducts heat well, so a silver-plated copper fake can pass. Treat it as a quick first check.

6. Ping test Free

Tapping a silver coin to make it ring, with a sound app open on a phone

Balance the coin on your fingertip and tap it gently with another coin. Real silver gives a long, clear, high-pitched ring. Most fakes make a short, dull clunk. Free phone apps can record the ring and compare it with the sound of a genuine coin of the same type, which takes the guesswork out.

The catch: it doesn’t work on coins in capsules or slabs, and background noise can confuse the apps.

7. Density test Under £20

A silver coin hanging on a thread inside a glass of water on a digital scale
The coin hangs on a thread, fully under water, without touching the glass.

Every metal has its own density. Pure silver’s is 10.49 g per cm³, while copper-nickel, a common fake material, is about 8.9. This test even catches plated fakes, because it measures the whole coin, not just the surface.

  1. Weigh the coin dry.
  2. Put a cup of water on the scale and press tare (zero). Then hang the coin from a thread so it sits fully under water, without touching the sides or bottom, and note the weight the scale shows.
  3. Divide the dry weight by that extra weight.

Example: a coin weighs 31.10 g dry, and the scale goes up by 2.96 g when it hangs in the water.

31.10 ÷ 2.96 = 10.5, which is right for 99.9% silver. A copper-nickel fake of the same size would give about 8.9.

You need a scale reading to 0.01 g, because small measuring errors make a big difference to the result.

8. Professional testers For dealers

A handheld precious metal verifier showing SILVER for a silver Britannia coin
  • Sigma Metalytics verifier: sends an electric signal through the coin and checks it reacts like silver all the way through, even inside a plastic capsule. Many serious collectors own one.
  • XRF analyser: shows exactly which metals are on the surface and in what amounts. Very accurate, but it only reads the surface, so dealers often use it alongside a Sigma.

Tests to avoid

  • Acid test Avoid: it means scratching the coin and putting acid on it, which permanently damages it and lowers its value.
  • Bite test Avoid: it won’t tell you anything about silver, and it damages the coin.

The safest way to avoid fakes

Testing at home helps, but the best protection is where you buy. Fakes mostly turn up on marketplaces, auction sites and through private sales at prices that look too good to be true. A UK dealer with a public address, VAT registration and independent reviews has every reason to sell only genuine coins.

Frequently asked questions

What is the easiest way to check a silver coin at home?

Weigh it on a 0.01 g scale and measure it with callipers, then compare both with the official figures. Add the magnet test. Together these catch most fakes in a couple of minutes.

Can a fake silver coin have the right weight?

Yes, but then it’s almost always the wrong size, because other metals have a different density from silver. That’s why weight and size should always be checked together.

Does a magnet stick to real silver?

No. If a magnet sticks, the coin isn’t silver. But many fakes aren’t magnetic either, so a magnet alone can’t prove a coin is real.

Are silver coins from Nova Numismatics genuine?

Yes. We sell genuine coins only, and you’re welcome to test anything you buy from us using any of the methods in this guide.

Buy silver you don’t need to worry about

Shop genuine silver coins from a UK dealer, or sell us the coins you already own.

Shop silver coinsSell your coins

This guide is general information. Home tests can only screen coins; if you have doubts about a valuable coin, have it checked by a dealer with professional testing equipment. Coin specifications are from the issuing mints.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.